Mrs. Henscher (full name Margot Henscher) is Blithe Hollow Middle School's drama teacher. She made a play based on Blithe Hollow's history and the witch's curse. She is shown to be overdramatic and passionate to the point of alienating others in moments of bombast even with Norman dealing with Aggie. She is voiced by Alex Borstein.
- "Ugh. You stink of literacy!"
- "Pilgrims - the mayflower - don't ANY of you know the history about this town?"
- When she is in school she wears a red beret on her head.
- At one point, Mrs. Henscher yells out "Cry havoc, and let slip the dogs of war!", a quote from William Shakespeare's play, Julius Caesar.
- Her name is Mrs. Henscher, but it is currently unknown who she is married to, maybe a man.